Their numbers continued to decline despite bringing in two of Twitch's biggest streamers. As a result, Shroud was paid $10 million, and Ninja scored an astounding $30 million payday, just to be released from their Mixer contract. Millions of fans tuned in every single day to watch their favorite streamers play video games. Of course, these are not official numbers. Unfortunately, their hopes did not translate to reality. Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories. We dont know where Warren got these numbers from. If you have a news tip or an app to review, hit him up atsean.endicott@futurenet.com (opens in new tab). Ninja Signs Exclusive Twitch Contract After Being Released from Mixer Deal Tim Daniels September 10, 2020 Paul Sancya/Associated Press Tyler "Ninja" Blevins announced Thursday he's. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. And then, Microsoft came along with an undisclosed offer and signed an exclusive contract with Ninja for its own streaming platform, Mixer, on Aug. 1. Ninja isn't the only big streamer to leave Twitch recently. Ninja has a lot of thinking to do. He's also rather excited for the Starfield release date. Like Google-owned YouTube dominates internet video-on-demand, such is Twitch's dominance of live-streamed internet video. Both Shroud and Ninja were offered double their Mixer contracts to make the switch to Facebook Gaming, however, neither took the bait. Microsoft acquired Mixer, formerly . The terms of the deal are, thus far, unknown but a new report says Microsoft paid Blevins "between $20 and $30 million" for a multi-year exclusivity deal. And third, that Ninja's . The $50 million amount is contrary to the previous rumored 100 million dollars contract between Ninja and Microsoft. By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider A new report from CNN Business claims that game streamer Tyler Blevins, better known as Ninja, will receive between $20 and $30 million from a multi-year deal with Mixer. I caught myself the other thinking "who would buy a gaming chair with an esport team's colors and logo?" It's just watching a jock play football games. A representative offered the following statement after publication:"We do not disclose the terms of any agreement for talent. Thank you for signing up to Windows Central. During the same time period, Twitch jumped from 850.6 million to 932.1 million, according to StreamElements data. He eventually began streaming H1Z1 in 2011 and then moved to playing PUBG. After joining Mixer back in late July of 2019, Ninja was eager to embark on a new journey in his streaming career outside of Twitch. He joined our team in 2017 as an app reviewer and now heads up our day-to-day news coverage. Sign up for notifications from Insider! Because once they sign, hes already committed. Some of the notable benefits included instant monetization and a direct line of feedback to the product and engineering team. This is clearly a meme, he did tag it as humor tho i dont think people believe it. And we were like, Straight up, guys, weve worked so, so hard to grow the Ninja brand to license things and get his name out there. Fortnite Cipher Quests - How to Get all Rewards, Fortnite Creed Cup and Creed Quests Breakdown, Fortnite: Ninja Declines A Reported $60-90 Million Offer To Join Facebook Gaming, 30 to 70 thousand average viewers on Twitch. Microsoft soon reached an agreement with Facebook, which granted former Mixer personalities the chance to jump ship. Tyler Blevins, better known as esports star Ninja, is reportedly bringing in a head-turning amount of money on the contract he signed with Mixer. This, combined with the fact that he began streaming the newly released Fortnite shortly thereafter, propelled him to internet stardom on Twitch. ninja mixer contract $932 million. The Ader team has no connection to this specific partnership and therefore any insight regarding the terms of the agreement is pure speculation.". Last but not least, he made a name for himself on Twitch and still maintains a fanbase to this day. Justin Warden, the CEO of agency Ader who represents the likes of former Overwatch pro Brandon Seagull Larned and League of Legends streamer and Team Liquid sub Ashkan TF Blade Homayouni claims that he had knowledge of the Ninja negotiations and believes that the multi-year Mixer deal was worth between $20 million and $30 million. When Mixer managed to tempt Twitchs biggest and most successful streamer, Tyler Ninja Blevins, to its streaming platform, it was pretty obvious that he would be getting a substantial payday. KEEM says this isn't confirmed and. Other sources in the CNN piece also give a rough scale as to how much a streamer can earn depending on their popularity, claiming that those who can average over 10,000 concurrent viewers every time they go live can expect contracts topping $10 million, while smaller streamers can expect around $1 million. Escape From Tarkov bids goodbye to flea market bartering, Atomic Hearts robot twins are sending fans to horny jail, Best Warzone 2 Resurgence loadout for bossing Ashika Island in Solos, Warzone 2 meta gets a TAQ-56 shake up for Ashika Island mayhem, 2023 new LoL champions include Milio, Naafiri, and a hangry jungler, Elden Ring DLC expansion is currently in development, The best IRL streamers and channels on Twitch, Who is Pokimane? Ludwig is making the next big Twitch game show for xQc, Amouranth invests $350k in Twitch content, is retiring from OnlyFans, Twitch employee Hassan fired following sexual misconduct investigation, Twitch's react meta might be good for streamers, but I cant stand it, Twitch is changing the cost of subs depending on where you live. Mixer shut down in July 2020. Bro you really dont understand the joke eh? Stay up to date with what you want to know. Ninja is no longer a Twitch streamer and hell only be on Mixer starting Aug. 2 with a broadcast from music festival Lollapalooza while playing in Friday Fortnite. This will be a multi-year deal for Ninja, and it is likely that this is the largest deal a streamer has been offered for streaming exclusivity. Amazon's Twitch is the most popular live video streaming service by a large margin. You will receive a verification email shortly. It was a leap of faith, and Microsofts been nothing but amazing to us.. This trend of major content creators departing the platform could very well be the beginning of the end for Twitch - and the rise ofMixer to take its place. Keeping that in mind, its a pretty huge move for Ninja to change platforms but it now makes sense given the fact that he was given $50 Million by Microsoft. The former Twitch and Mixer star had no shortage of offers on the table. Tyler has called Mixer home for a few months, and while hes boasted some impressive viewership numbers, the streaming platform still doesnt hold a candle to Twitchs dominance. Ninja reportedly got paid between $20 million and $30 million by Microsoft to leave Amazon's Twitch streaming service Ben Gilbert Tyler "Ninja" Blevins announced his intention to leave. The former Halo pro turned Fortnite sensation left 14 million followers and hundreds of thousands of subscribers behind him. Forsen went on to estimate the price point for Ninja's deal . Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, Microsoft has Xbox + Mixer + xCloud. He's just a smart businessman, that's all. Blevins' talent representation at Loaded, the company that negotiated the Mixer deal, initially declined to comment. In the latest edition of his Drama Alert show, he says that the rumor around the street is that Ninja may have secured $100 million from his Mixer deal. Other popular streamers are rumoured to be offered contracts up to $10 million. This fits with Forsen's breakdown predicting Ninja's contract being between $6 and $8 million per year. Ninja signed an exclusive deal with Mixer last year. It does make sense as a lot of people will watch Ninja play games on Mixer soon and that will allow them to jump straight to the game via Project xCloud. Ninja reportedly said no, ultimately passing on an offer that would indisputably make him one of the wealthiest gamers of all time. 26, Sensor Towers head of mobile insights Randy Nelson said. "I know this may come as a shock to many of you," he said, "but, as of today, I will be streaming exclusively on Mixer. And it largely started with a single departure.". He took a conservative approach and he estimates that Ninja is on a contract that will give him between $6 million and $8 million a year for at least three years. The two are now free agents able to play the field as their suss out their next streaming home. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. 936 million - Baseball players aren't even getting that kind of money. We estimate that the app was installed by 26,000 new users yesterday worldwide across the App Store and Google Play. Microsoft paid over $50 Million to bring Ninja to stream exclusively on Mixer, according to The Verge's senior editor, Tom Warren. He was offered 90m to come finish out the time on FB platform and he said no. Twitch has long been the undisputed leader of video game streaming. But many people are curious to know how much money Mixer offered Ninja to move to its platform. Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. Then, on June 22, Microsoft suddenly announced plans to close Mixer. But Blevins manager and wife, Jessica Blevins, told Business Insider that Tylers decision to leave Twitch and move over to the Microsoft-owned streaming service Mixer in August wasnt just a financial one. It's worth noting that he means $6-to-$8 million a year, for three years. Tyler Blevins, better known by his online persona Ninja, reportedly received 20-30 million dollars to move from Twitch to Microsoft's Mixer. Ninja reportedly paid $30m to end Mixer contract as streaming platform merges with Facebook Gaming, shroud receives $10m Daniel Conlan Published: Jun 22nd, 2020, 19:03 The two streamer superstars are free to join a platform and Mixer may have had to pay them millions of dollars for the privilege. This figure comes from Justin Warden, who is the . One of these offers would see Ninja agree to a contract buyout with Mixer, which would grant him the $30 million promised in his original contract. He also got a big payday to basically do what he was doing before but on a different network. Both Jessica and Tyler brought their concerns to Twitch over the course of several months, but the company failed to respect their wishes, she said. For example, streamer Disguised Toast recently abandoned Twitch to begin working with Facebook Gaming. When asked where he would end up by viewers, he has demurred. He was already so big on Twitch that his move surprised a lot of people, something he recognized would happen and that he joked about in his Mixer announcement video. In the latest edition of his Drama Alert show, he says that "the rumor around the street" is that Ninja may have secured $100 million from his Mixer deal. The $50 million amount is contrary to the previous rumored. It would not be a huge surprise to see Ninja make his triumphant return to Twitch soon. Stay up to date with what you want to know. The partnership did not last long, however, as Mixer struggled to keep up with rival platforms Twitch and YouTube Gaming. No matter where you choose to stream, the world is better with your gaming content in it. New data, released by StreamElements in partnership with streaming analytics site Arsenal.gg, discovered that hours watched on Mixer jumped about 3 million (from 37.7 million to 40.2 million) the month that Tyler joined. He did not state how many years the deal lasts, however. Furthermore, Tom Warren said that Microsoft didnt hire Ninja to promote Mixer alone. While these values havent been officially verified, the Ninja Mixer deal would significantly bolster Ninjas net worth, which he has built not only from streaming but also sponsorship deals, YouTube revenue, and merchandise sales. This isnt about selling Xbox consoles. Justin Warden, CEO of the marketing and talent management agency Ader, which works with Ninja, revealed as much to Shannon Liao of CNN Business. Pretty much. Tyler Blevins, better known as esports star Ninja, is reportedly bringing in a head-turning amount of money on the contract he signed with Mixer. The Metro UK reports the number for Ninja to join Facebook Gaming was $60 million while Shroud was offered $20 million. In 2017 his skills at PUBG were so well-developed that he actually won the PUBG Gamescom Invitational Squads classification. Because its fun to watch professionals do things you are interested in. New data, released by StreamElements in partnership with streaming analytics site Arsenal.gg, discovered that hours watched on Mixer jumped about 3 million (from 37.7 million to 40.2. You're watching someone you enjoy watching doing something that you like to watch. Blevins signed an exclusive streaming deal with Mixer last August. craigslist hattiesburg ms community ; cottonwood financial administrative services, llc; disney channel september 2002 ninja mixer contract $932 million Jamie Hore Jamie started out his journalism career rambling about FIFA esports, but today he covers much more,like the bestWarzone guns and theApex Legends tier list. We can keep sources anonymous. Please refresh the page and try again. But..why? The service shuttered on July 22, and any existing streamers were re-routed to Facebook Gaming, the social network's own Twitch rival. Justin Warden, CEO of the marketing and talent management agency Ader, which works with Ninja, revealed as much to. Warden gave the figure to CNN Business, and claimed he had "direct knowledge" of the terms of the deal. Ninja made his faith in Mixer known to both his audience and those who were quick to poke fun at his choice. Nothing but respect for him. Lol, maybe you should go back to school since you get triggered by a satire post, idiot. Ninja's Move to Mixer Made Him $20-30 Million, Popular Fortnite Pro Twitch Streamer Paid Off His Mom's Student Loans, Disguised Toast recently abandoned Twitch, Twitch has lost the majority of it's top video game streamers, While Twitch has attempted to counter these offers, Twitch Streamers Cash-Crazed Rant Making Onlookers Furious - Heres Why. Critics took aim at Ninja, stating that his move revolved only around the money. Mixer became the butt of almost every joke across social media. But no one passes on $90 million without an end game. According to his sources, Twitch is not the only option for Ninja. Tyler Ninja Blevins surprising departure from Twitch came after months of feeling like the company didnt respect his wishes and hindered his ability to grow outside of gaming. Hes back to that energetic, pumped-up Ninja, she said. The terms of the deal were not disclosed. Rumors of Mixers issues soon came to fruition. Shroud and Ninja both opted to have their Mixer contracts paid out, with Ninja pocketing $30 million and Shroud pocketing $10 million. Ader is a marketing and talent management agency that works with Ninja. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Two, that any exclusivity deal Ninja accepted is likely paying him between $3 and $10 million a year. As the market grew though, a significant portion of large tech companies decided to use their checkbooks to take Twitch's highest profile stars. Yup - actual reports are 6 - 8 million for 5 years + endorsement deals from everything xbox, PC, and all MS products. Esports News Fortnite Fortnite: Ninja Declines A Reported $60-90 Million Offer To Join Facebook Gaming, 21+ | Commercial Content | T&Cs apply | Play Responsibly. 2023 ESTNN: Esports News Network. Blevins apparently cashed in on that departure. You honestly think Microsoft is going to pay close to a billion dollars for Ninja lmao. However, the true worth of Ninjas contract, and the contracts of other streamers who have either left or renegotiated with Twitch, may have just been revealed. It was the streamer's sizable audience that gave him the leverage to negotiate such a lucrative contract, Warden said. Then I quickly remembered that I own several jerseys, shirts, and hats for teams that I route for. Google has YouTube + Stadia and Amazon has Twitch. Money was the last thing on our mind, she said. Despite those estimates, only Ninja and Mixer can confirm what the deal was and how much money is involved. Ninja, now 29 years of age, started on Twitch and grew into one of the most recognizable gamers after years of hard work. Its two superstars in Ninja and Shroud prepared to hit the road and never look back. But..why? What is next for one of the worlds most popular gamers? Prior to his retirement from Twitch he owned the most subscribed channel at 14 million followers. We include affiliate links in articles. The developer supported, community run subreddit dedicated to the Fortnite: Battle Royale game mode by Epic Games. Microsoft's announced today that they will be shutting down Mixer and transitioning all of their streaming partners over to Facebook Gaming. With the wording of how that contract was going, he wouldnt have been able to grow his brand much outside of gaming, Blevins told Business Insider. an estimated total earnings of $10 million in 2018, an exclusive contract with Ninja for its own streaming platform, Mixer, It's official: Cloud9 VALORANT parts ways with Yay after 5 months, Here are the early LoL Patch 13.5 patch notes, Ludwig's $500,000 VALORANT team becomes instant meme after disappointing Challengers debut, 100 Thieves content creator Kyedae diagnosed with leukemia, One champion is dominating Challenger with stunning 60 percent win rate in LoL Patch 13.4. When Mixer signed Ninja, he had 14.7 million followers on Twitch. And third . Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. As the operations side of @WatchMixer is closing, we are inviting the Mixer Community to #FacebookGaming. as well as other partner offers and accept our. It will be a tough decision without a doubt. / Sign up for Verge Deals to get deals on products we've tested sent to your inbox daily. Blevins announced his decision to leave. People are dumb. I admit that I don't watch streamers, but I do watch a ton of other sports. Its like, they dont even know what went on behind the scenes and how hard we tried to make that deal work and then how amazing Microsoft was for us.. And third, that Ninja's exclusivity contract is for multiple years. Ninja announced through his different social media accounts that hes leaving Twitch to stream exclusively on Microsofts Mixer video streaming platform. While many suspected his departure from Amazon's Twitch came with a hefty contract, no financial details emerged from the deal until this point. Just why? Yet, despite Facebook doubling those amounts, both streamers refused the deals. Ninja has 2.8 million followers on Mixer, Microsoft's nascent gaming platform, which Forbes estimates spent $30 million over three years to lure him away from arch-rival Twitch last August. Streamer Tyler Blevins, better known as Ninja, reportedly receives $20-$30 million dollars for his streaming exclusivity deal with Mixer. Heres how it works. PR pitches by email only, please. https://t.co/lvn9KBjEYq https://t.co/tljVgyM3bG. Now, just ten months into his three-year contract, Ninja is the most sought after free agent in the streaming market today. Ninja was the first major streamer Microsoft's streaming service signed. The future is looking bright for Microsoft. As Google-owned YouTube dominates internet video-on-demand, Twitch dominates live-streamed internet video. So far, nothing has been revealed or leaked, so we have to stick with these estimates for now. NY 10036. By March of 2018 Ninja had over 2 million subscribers to his Twitch channel. Since leaving Twitch, Tyler has scored major deals with companies like Adidas, and has a small role in Ryan Reynolds new movie, Free Guy. Hundreds of thousands of people are watching live video streams on the service at any moment. During this time period he played for several professional gaming teams like Team Liquid and Luminosity Gaming. The other saw Facebook Gaming offer a rumored $90 million if he decided to move over with the gobs of different Mixer personalities. He went from 30 to 70 thousand average viewers on Twitch to between 3 and 10 thousand on Mixer. In an effort to compete with Amazon, Microsoft spent tens of millions of dollars on two particularly high-profile exclusivity deals with the two highest-profile streamers: Blevins and Michael "Shroud" Grzesiek. Sign up for our newsletter for the latest tech news and scoops delivered daily to your inbox. Next: Twitch Streamers Cash-Crazed Rant Making Onlookers Furious - Heres Why. Ader told CNN Business that he had direct knowledge of the deal, so it's more reputable information than some rumors that appeared on Reddit following Blevins' move to Mixer. I totally get why people are though. Sources familiar with the deal have informed me that while Facebook did try and negotiate to keep their big partners both Shroud and Ninja opted out. But a talent management executive who's worked with Blevins told CNN Businessin an article published Mondaythat the streamer may netted between $20 million and $30 million from the deal. You wouldnt sign anything less than three years, but I dont think Mixer would like to sign for more than three years, forsen said. Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories. The largest individual sports contract in history was $430M to Mike Trout over 12 years. Sign up for our newsletter for the latest tech news and scoops delivered daily to your inbox. The deal soundsexpensive, and six months later, we may have finally learned exactly how expensive the deal was: "Between $20 and $30 million" for a "multi-year deal," according to Ader CEO Justin Warden, whose marketing and talent management company reportedly works with Blevins. Ninja signed a three-year contract worth reportedly $30 million. Details of the contract have not been released, so it's unknown how much is mixer paying Ninja. Microsoft hoped that these acquisitions would boost their numbers. It was a sizable hit to Ninja, considering his rise to fame in the early days of Fortnite and catastrophic numbers on Twitch. Tyler "Ninja" Blevins is streaming on Twitch for the first time since he signed an exclusivity deal with Mixer in 2019. A new report from CNN Business claims that game streamer Tyler. Until his departure in 2019, Blevins was Twitch's most popular streamer. Ninja signed a three-year contract worth reportedly $30 million. By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider I love my community and what we built together on Mixer. Related: Popular Fortnite Pro Twitch Streamer Paid Off His Mom's Student Loans. There was a problem. Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab). The next chapter, penn township hanover, pa map . While Ninja was forced to leave behind his followers on Twitch, he gained over one million followers on Mixer in less than a week - though part of that was due to the free subscription promotion Mixer ran to celebrate his addition to the platform. Twitch remains in a partnership with Amazon Prime, which offers a free subscription to any viewer with a Prime account. One, that Ninja has been fielding exclusivity offers for some time, whether that be Facebook, YouTube, Mixer, or Twitch itself. Why did Microsoft pay ~$50 million+ to get Ninja on Mixer? Twitch streamer Sebastian Forsen Fors gave his own educated guess based on his experience as a big streamer and former professional Starcraft and Hearthstone player. She added that it really seemed like he was kind of losing himself and his love for streaming. Things are different now on Mixer a streaming platform that has gained recognition for its stricter community guidelines pertaining to user behavior. Honestly I'm not much into eSports, but I'm also not much into regular sports as a spectator either. "I really took my time to decide which platform was best," Blevins said in the announcement, "and Twitch has been very supportive throughout this process and understanding my overall career goals.". The number comes from Justin Warden, who is the CEO of Ader, the talent agency that works with Blevins. We cant go backwards with it.. There were already conflicts with his current sponsors and re-signing with that platform. Graduated from Midwestern State University with a BA in English where he worked as an editor for the University literary journal. Sign up for Verge Deals to get deals on products we've tested sent to your inbox daily. This information comes from Justin Warden, who is the CEO of marketing and talent management of company Ader, who claims to have an inside source that informed him of the deal. New York, Famed esports insider Rob Slasher Breslau has been knee-deep in the news since Mixer announced that it would shut down its service. That was Ninja. Mixer became the butt of almost every joke across social media. Streamer Tyler Blevins, better known as Ninja, reportedly receives $20-$30 million dollars for his streaming exclusivity deal with Mixer. Sean Endicott brings nearly a decade of experience covering Microsoft and Windows news to Windows Central. You dont do longer contracts in esports longer than three years.. Ninja still hasn't announced any concrete plans, but he booted up his Twitch channel in. That service was shuttered suddenly earlier this summer, making him and other high-profile streamers Microsoft had paid into free agents once again. Its quite a drop off considering Ninjas been absent from Twitch for almost a full year. Reports from esports journalist and consultant Rod 'Slasher' Breslau are suggesting that the two marquee streamers that helped put Mixer's name on the map, Tyler 'Ninja' Blevins and Michael 'Shroud' Grzesiek, have had their multi-million dollar contracts paid out by Mixer, meaning they are now free to stream wherever they want. It's just watching a geek play computer games. Fortnite streamer Tyler Ninja Blevins was living the dream on Twitch. Mixer ultimately offered their loyal streamers an opportunity to join Facebook Gaming as a consolation for all of their hard work in building their brand under the Microsoft umbrella. That's a fake Twitter. ", The announcement itself was lighthearted and silly, but the news was anything but the world's most popular, well-known video game streamer was switching from Amazon to Microsoft. Going forward, beyond playing "Fortnite" live on streams, Blevins said his focus will be "to elevate and bring more eyes to underrepresented creators. This was an increase of +86% versus the previous days 14,000 new installs and +100% week-over-week from 13,000 on Thursday, Jul. Cody Peterson is an avid reader and writer. But it's a safe bet that Microsoft has cut Ninja some sort of advantageous financial deal to . Veteran Gamer, Trophy Hunter, And a Youtuber. They have received their full payments and as of midnight yesterday were free to engage in talks with other platforms. As of Thursday's announcement, both Blevins and Grzesiek have since returned to Twitch. The Mixer app currently sits at 3rd place on the App Store. Im surprised a lot of people didnt know what my tweet was about. Twitch effectively was limiting Tylers ability to grow as more than just a gaming personality on the platform, she argued. In a last-ditch effort, Microsoft made the wise decision to collaborate with Facebooks streaming platform, dubbed Facebook Gaming. Liao noted Blevins previously said he made approximately $10 million in 2018. Tyler Blevins, better known by his online persona Ninja, reportedly received 20-30 million dollars to move from Twitch to Microsoft's Mixer. Tyler Ninja Blevins, whos known as the most popular streamer on Twitch is now shifting to a new platform. When CNN Business reached out to Microsoft to receive confirmation of the deal, Microsoft directed CNN Business to Ninja's agency, Loaded. Ninja signed an exclusive deal with Mixer last year. Rod Breslau (@Slasher) June 22, 2020. However, Mixer comes at the first if we exclude video game applications. Ninjas move to Mixer turned out to not be the game changer they probably hoped when comparing their market share with Twitchs, StreamElements CEO Doron Nir said. It all started with Tyler "Ninja" Blevins last August. All Rights Reserved, By submitting your email, you agree to our. On the other hand, Mixer is now the 12th-most-popular app on Google Play Store. The Google subsidiary features one of the worlds most popular gamers, Felix PewDiePie Kjellberg. But Twitch is bleeding: a major talent exodus has more people than ever using competing services from Microsoft and Google. hes boasted some impressive viewership numbers, Some Pixel phones are crashing after playing a certain YouTube video, Snapchat is releasing its own AI chatbot powered by ChatGPT, The McRib Locator continues to live on after the sandwichs farewell tour, On the internet,nobody knows youre a human. Then, this past June, Microsoft announced the sudden closure of Mixer making Ninja a free agent once again.
Charlie Mccarthy Doll,
Lance D Johnson Biography,
Fort Pierce City Marina Tides,
Articles N
ninja mixer contract $932 millionLeave a reply